Jump to content


Photo

What's going on with Genetica?


  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 McGyver

McGyver

    Newbie

  • Full Members
  • Pip
  • 6 posts

Posted 23 July 2017 - 10:37 AM

I know this is pointless to post this, but I came back here to see how Genetica is doing...
Looking around in this forum I found a curious post that I'm not sure if I'm interpreting correctly...
And honestly I don't know what to make of it.

A few years back I was strictly a Mac user and when I decided between purchasing either Filter Forge or Genetica, there really was no choosing as only Filter Forge works on Macs...

For a few years now, I've been a Windows user and Genetica is an option... So every now and again, I check back on Genetica, hoping for a sale or something... Sorry, but the things I'd use Genetica for are hobby related and I don't have a lot of money to spend on texturing my freebie models I give away.

I understand that this is a very professional, capable and sophisticated program... But...
The hobby segment is kinda big and it kinda seems like less and less people in the hobby segment know about Genetica when I mention it on other forums, or that people I know tend to purchase Filter Forge over Genetica in the end.

This is kind of a shame, because both tools are pretty damn good and it seems like this one is kinda fading or becoming less well known.
That might just be my stupid perspective, or a misinterpretation, but anyway...

I really believe Genetica is a great tool, I tried the demo a long time ago, and occasionally use Viewer...
I thank Spiral Graphics for making that available for free, and because I often mention Viewer, I try to always promote or equally mention Genetica as an option when discussing texturing tools like Filter Forge and such, in forum discussions at whatever 3D sites I frequent.

Unfortunately for Spiral Graphics, more often than not the person whom I was discussing this with, buys Filter Forge.
And the reasons are always the same...
A huge library of premade royalty free filters and lots and lots of big sales.

I don't want to tell anyone how to do business or imply I know better, but I think it would be a huge boost to Genetica to do or at least try out two things...

1- Have more sales...
I can't remember the last one I came across and it was long over when I found it.
I know people sometimes feel this is gimmicky or it undermines the value of a product or they get insulted that someone doesn't feel the product is worth the price... But some people just can't afford good stuff sometimes and the fact is sometimes discount offers drive sales and drive awareness.

2- Make a section for registered users (people who purchased Genetica) to contribute and share Free Filters (sorry if that is a wrong use of terminology).
I get that Viewer is completely free and there is a big selection of filters, but it probably looks tiny to anyone who compares it to Filter Forge's library.
And many many times I've been told that was a deciding factor.
Sometimes people don't want to immediately have to learn how to make filters, they are happy altering available ones and going from there.

I'm pretty sure nothing will come of these suggestions because the odds of anyone reading this, who could do anything with these suggestions, if anyone might actually consider what some knucklehead out of the blue is suggesting is slim to highly unlikely.

It's kinda sad that after years of plugging and suggesting Genetica... I still don't own it because I can't really afford it.
Granted I could save up for it, but the fact is I did that a few times and ended up purchasing 3D software or upgrades to other software that was on sale instead, mostly because of the rarity of sales at Spiral Graphics and me feeling the odds of getting Genetica on sale were slim, so why waste the opportunity for a good bargain on the off chance I might find a sale eventually.

Sorry to waste forum space on a post that is in all likelihood a waste of time, but it's sort of the best contribution I can make (besides just shutting up and paying full price)... Not just because I'd like to eventually get Genetica, but because I'd hate to see Genetica just fade away.

Seriously... This is a great product!

Well... Good luck.

Edited by McGyver, 23 July 2017 - 10:42 AM.


#2 Sign Guy

Sign Guy

    Active Member

  • Full Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 51 posts

Posted 23 July 2017 - 12:40 PM

For the record ...

 

I am a licensee of both Filter Forge and Genetica. I agree with you that Genetica is a great product, but primarily because it suits my needs much better than Filter Forge. I stopped upgrading Filter Forge back at version 3 and it is safe to say that Filter Forge users pay a lot more than Genetica users if they stay in the upgrade path.

 

The Filter Forge filter library you point out has two primary drawbacks. 1) If you don't have the latest version of Filter Forge, most of the filters won't work. 2) Easily four out of five filters has flaws and would be considered useless by most users.

 

In addition, Filter Forge is incredibly slow at rendering images and previewing changes. The publisher has openly admitted that they made a bad programming choice early on and the lack of speed will never be fixed. It isn't unusual for a render to take more than 60 minutes at a size of 3600 x 3600 pixels.

 

Filter Forge is based around manipulating Perlin noise and is poor at working with photos. Genetica is superb at working with photos. That feature alone has earned me back the price of Genetica a hundred fold and my photo tiles sell well on a number of stock sites. Check them out for yourself:

 

https://www.allcompu...se=photographic

 

https://www.allcompu...erflies-04.html

 

https://www.allcompu...8/Candy-02.html


Edited by Sign Guy, 23 July 2017 - 12:42 PM.

Fred Weiss
Allied Computer Graphics, Inc.




1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users